Negotiating Divorce: Ethics, Harm, and Judicial Annulment in Hanbali Law and Saudi Arabia
This paper examines women’s utilization of judicial annulment (faskh al-nikāḥ) within Hanbali jurisprudence and its contemporary application in Saudi Arabian personal status courts. Treating marriage as a contract with reciprocal rights, the author argues that female-initiated faskh serves as both a legal strategy and an ethical practice rooted in Islamic principles of removing harm (ḍarar) and preserving human dignity. Through a textual analysis of classical Hanbali jurists—including Ibn Qudāmah, Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn al-Qayyim, and al-Buhūtī—the study outlines recognized grounds for annulment, such as bodily defects, financial neglect, prolonged absence, and physical or emotional abuse. The paper then analyzes five published Saudi court decisions, evaluating how modern judges navigate an uncodified legal system to apply classical Hanbali doctrine to contemporary marital disputes, including cases involving drug abuse, criminal records, and marital discord. Findings demonstrate that while Saudi courts show increasing responsiveness to women’s claims by expanding definitions of harm, female legal agency remains constrained by classical gender paradigms that mandate proving male failure or returning dower compensation.